The MTA: Going Your Way Very Slowly. The Port Authority: Not Going Your Way At All.
I flew up to Vermont over the weekend for a ski trip. Flying seems a little unnecessary, because in the time it takes to leave the house, sit in the airport, take off, fly, land, and get transportation to the mountain, you could easily drive there from New York. But at least I didn’t have the potential to become a perpetrator of an infamous road rage incident after sitting in traffic on the Connecticut Turnpike for two hours.
The flight left JFK at 9:25am on Friday morning. I stayed overnight in Prospect Heights in Brooklyn so I wouldn’t have to get up as early to catch the flight. I was planning to leave for the airport around 7, but it took less time than I expected to get dressed and ready, so I stepped out of the house at 6:45 - 2 hours and 40 minutes before my flight.
Considering that I could get stuck in rush hour traffic, I figured that the most logical means of getting to the airport was via the subway and Airtrain. Not only that, but I’m a poor-ass mofo, and I wasn’t about to spend a crapload of money to sit in rush-hour traffic on the Belt Parkway and possibly miss my train.
So, instead, I would take the C Train to the A Train to the Airtrain. It seemed simple enough, and shouldn’t take more than an hour.
When I got to the C Train platform at Franklin Avenue, I waited less than five minutes for the train. Things seemed to be going smoothly. I got off at the next express stop, Nostrand Avenue, and waited patiently for the next A Train. The train that came was a Lefferts Boulevard-bound train. In my morning grogginess, I failed to notice this until I got on, so I got off at the next stop and waited for an A Train that would actually take me to JFK.
And waited.
And waited.
And waited.
At 7:15 in the morning - well into what the MTA considers the morning rush hour - I waited 45 MINUTES for the next A Train to pull in.
Not just a Far Rockaway-bound train. Any train. Eight A Trains pulled through in the opposite direction while I waited.
It’s one thing to wait 45 minutes for a train. It’s another to wait 45 minutes and not hear a single announcement informing you that you’ll be waiting 45 minutes, or why the hell an A Train hasn’t come through the station in 45 FUCKING MINUTES AT RUSH HOUR.
Had I known of the delay, I could’ve taken a C Train to Broadway Junction and taken the J Train to Jamaica to connect to the Airtrain there. Problem solved. I was about to exercise that option when an A Train finally arrived, and I crammed into a crowded train with other passengers - who must not have been in much of a hurry, since none of them looked particularly perturbed with the delay.
It’s still unclear why the A Train wasn’t running on Friday morning. There were no service alerts on the MTA website. There were no news stories about it. Unless I missed an invisible train while standing on the platform, there is no explanation for why there was a 45 minute gap in service on the A during rush hour.
At this point, I was already cutting it close. I would barely make it to the airport 45 minutes before my flight. I never cut it that close. I pictured myself tapping my foot impatiently while I stood in line for security, and then scurrying through the terminal to make my flight.
I hopped on the Airtrain at Howard Beach at about 8:20. This train, which is run by the Port Authority, is completely automated and a complete rip-off for a ride not much longer than the Cyclone at Coney Island (at nearly the same cost), but it has never given me any problems. I would simply take the train five stops to the station for Terminal 6, and I’d be good to go.
Little did I know that the Airtrain also has the reliability of a decrepit wooden roller coaster built in the early 20th century.
When the train pulled into Terminal 4, the last stop before my terminal, it stopped. Its doors opened as usual, and then they sat open at the station. Then we waited.
And waited.
And waited.
And waited.
It was now 8:40. I figured I was completely and utterly screwed at this point. I called JetBlue and was informed that I had until 30 minutes prior to departure to check in. I had 15 minutes.
“Attention ladies and gentlemen, please clear this train,” I finally hear over the loudspeaker. Where did the voice come from? I have no idea. There isn’t a conductor on the train. It must be the voice of God. ”This train is going out of service and moving in the opposite direction.” I’m pretty sure that’s what the announcement said, but it sounded more like “FIWTYNSJKDNF IOHYWEN WERTRJGNF HFA SDFIH TYHNVXN.”
An Airtrain pulled into the station going in the opposite direction, so I darted across the platform. That train simply runs in a loop to all of the terminals, so I figured I could still make it to Terminal 6 in fifteen minutes. We pulled out and headed around the airport - first at Terminals 2 and 3, then at Terminal 1. Things were moving smoothly.
Then, at Terminal 1, that same voice of God announced that the Airtrain would finally compensate for the broken-down train and head back in the same direction we had just come from. So, we passed through Terminals 2 and 3 again, then Terminal 4, and finally - at long last - Terminals 5 and 6. I ran through the airport and managed to check-in at 8:51, just 4 minutes before I would be shut out of my flight.
The rest of the airport experience is a blur, but it included a ticketing agent who swore I had no chance of making my flight, an angry TSA agent who threatened us, a swarm of parents with strollers who I cussed out for getting in my way, a shuttle bus ride, a mad dash through a “temporary satellite terminal,” and a 25-minute flight delay that made all of that rushing completely unnecessary.
In the end, it took 2 hours and 10 minutes to get from Brooklyn to JFK. So much for rapid transit. Suddenly, LaGuardia isn’t sounding half bad anymore.
This entry was posted on Tuesday, January 22nd, 2008 at 11:12 am and is filed under Subway Stupidity. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

January 22nd, 2008 at 1:04 pm
The Brooklyn Boy says:Damn, dude. That is BRUTAL. Glad you made it though.
January 22nd, 2008 at 1:58 pm
Jon says:Wouldn’t it have been faster to take the LIRR to Jamaica? That train probably runs on time, although you still would have faced the AirTrain debacle. It seems ridiculous the NYC area airports are so difficult to get to using mass transit.
January 22nd, 2008 at 2:03 pm
lozo says:you know what this story needs? a gun.
January 22nd, 2008 at 2:05 pm
Gwin says:Jon: the LIRR to Jamaica is a good alternative — however, if you live on the LES or the East Village, it feels coutnerintuitive to go all the way up to Penn Station, only to go back down and over again to get to JFK.
I had a parallel experience to this on Christmas Day, actually. I had a 9 AM flight out of JFK to Virginia, and since I live on the LES I decided to catch the F to the A to the AirTrain. I did this on Thanksgiving and it took about an hour - no problem.
So at 7 AM I went to East Broadway to wait for the F. I waited…and waited…and waited. At 8:20 a train finally pulled in… and I was able to hop an A train at Borough Hall at roughly 8:30. By this time I was a little concerned, because I wasn’t counting on half my travel time taken up by 2 stops on the F.
THEN I realized the A train goes local when it’s on a Sunday schedule (which is what it does on Christmas, apparently). So I hopped off and rushed out to the street - I was in the middle of Brooklyn somewhere, although I’m not sure where. I called Arecibo (the only car service I know in Brooklyn) and they got me to the airport by 8:10. Of course, then my flight was delayed anyway!!
Also, even though I picked up the car service well into Brooklyn, it still cost me $33 (then I gave the guy a $17 tip since it was Christmas, for cryin’ out loud). So yeah, a $50 trip to the airport for a flight that was delayed 45 minutes. Lame.
January 22nd, 2008 at 3:00 pm
Casey says:Wow.
January 22nd, 2008 at 4:08 pm
Jack Goes Forth says:Is going on “weekend excursions” ever worth the trouble? I’m just getting over my hangover and the massive amount of money I had to spend(gas, unneccessary meals, drinks,etc) on my last weekend trip. It makes staying at home, youporn and a 24 pack of Coors Light that much more appealing.
January 23rd, 2008 at 5:08 pm
Ryan says:How was the skiing?
I went to Killington two weekends ago and it was wicked icy. I almost died. It was fun.
January 23rd, 2008 at 7:58 pm
keith says:you live downtown. newark is so much easier. cab to penn sta (or, if you’re feeling particularly masochistic, l train to 1/9 to penn sta), then njt for an 18-minute ride to the airport. actually the airtran. once (in the 100 or so times i’ve taken it) did i also get fucked by the airtran, which took 45 minutes to take the 3 minute trip from the rail station to terminal c.)
which is a long way of saying … newark is so much easier from downtown. and the lines or shorter and the delays considerably less than jfk or lga.
January 24th, 2008 at 1:21 pm
Gwin says:Newark is definitely easier — however, if you want to take JetBlue anywhere, JFK is the most likely option.
January 24th, 2008 at 3:06 pm
Sarah says:Just make sure you take NJT, not Amtrak, to Newark Airport. Amtrak charges something like three times as much!
January 24th, 2008 at 8:44 pm
Jill says:The Carey bus from Grand Central is the best way to get to the airport, it’s only $10 or $15 and leaves pretty frequently. Last summer I took the airtrain to JFK from the East Village on a Sunday morning and it took over 2 hours. Never again.
January 27th, 2008 at 10:05 pm
*Red says:LaGuardia is the only way to go for me. JFK is just a mess of idiots. Sure LaGuardia is shitty and run down, but it only takes 20 minutes and a $20 Super Shuttle ride to get there from the E.Village.
January 29th, 2010 at 3:59 am
Norris Pigat says:I have to agree and found this very interesting